Proposed Roads to Freedom

e filled with the thought of the possessions that others may take from them, than of the jo

that life sho

est they should lose such affection and respect as they receive: they are engaged in giving affection and respect freely, and the reward comes of itself without their seeking. In their work they are not haunted by jealousy of competitors, but concerned with the actual matter that has to be done. In

this way in spite of obstacles and discouragement, there would be no need for the regeneration of the world to begin by political and economic reform: all that is needed in the way of reform would come automatically, without resistance, owing to the moral regeneration of individuals. But the teaching of Christ has been nominally accepted by the world for many centuries, and yet those who follow it are still persecuted as they were before the time of Constantine. Experience has

Second, we may put those that spring from defects in the character or aptitudes of the sufferer: among these are ignorance, lack of will, and violent passions. These we will call ``evils of character.'' Third come those that depend upon the power of one individual or group over anothe

rth yield its fruits in any abundance without labor, but we can diminish the amount of the labor and improve its conditions until it ceases to be an evil. Evils of character are often the result of physical evil in the shape of illness, and still more often the result of evils of power, since tyranny degrades both those who exercise it and (as a rule) those who suffer it. Evils of power are intensified by evils of character in

cal and economic organization of society in such a way as to reduce to the lowest possible point the interference of one man with the life of another. We will begin with the third of these kinds of evil, because it is evils of power specially

ental evil in our modern Society w

ought to answer SLAVERY. Face to face every day with the shameful contrasts of riches and destitution, high dividends and low wages, and painfully conscious of t

ialist is with them. But their answer

bondage. The many are not enslaved because they are poor, they are poor because they are enslaved. Yet Socialists have all too often

n Industry,'' G. Bell &

Almost all are compelled to work so hard that they have little leisure for enjoyment or for pursuits outside their regular occupation. Those who are able to retire in later middle age are bored, because they have not learned how to fill their time when they are at liberty, and such interests as they once had apart from work have dried up. Yet these are the exceptionally fortunate: the majority have to work hard till old age, with the fear of destitution always before them, the richer ones dreading that they will be unable t

another's pain, if they could be induced to work constructively for improvements which they would share with all the world rather than destructively to prevent

tem would be the best? In what direction sh

t far removed from that advocated by Kropotkin, but rendered more practicable by the adoption of the main principles of Guild Soc

velihood, and be left completely free; but probably it would be desirable that there should be a strong public opinion in favor of work, so that only comparatively few should choose idleness. One great advantage of making idleness economically possible is that it would afford a powerful motive for making work not disagreeable; and

where there is a much higher level of technical instruction than there is now the same tendency will be accentuated. People will be taught not only, as at present, one trade, or one small portion of a trade, but several trades, so that they can vary their occupation according to the seasons and the fluctuations of demand. Every industry will be self-governing as regards all its internal affairs, and even separate factories will decide for themselves all questions that only con

ttle to do. The dread of unemployment and loss of livelihood will no longer haunt men like a nightmare. Whether all who are willing to work will be paid equally, or whether exceptional skill will still command exceptional pay, is a matter which may be left to each guild to dec

n could be attracted into these by higher pay or shorter hours, instead of being driven into them by destitution. The communi

in another. When the day comes for distributing luxuries, old ladies will not want their quota of cigars, nor young men their just proportion of lap-dog; this will make it necessary to know how many cigars are the equivalent of one lap-dog. Much the simplest way is to pay an income, as at present, and allow relative values to

he question whether this plan should be adopted is, to my mind, a purely technical one: would it be, in fact, possible to adopt it without much waste and consequent diversion of labor to the production of necessaries when it might be more usefully employed otherwi

industry. This will secure the complete economic independence of wives, which is difficult to achieve

t present; greater care will be taken to adapt it to the needs of different types of young people. There will be more attempt to encourage initiative young pupils, and less desire to fill their minds with a set of beliefs and mental habits regarded as desirable by the State, chiefly because they help to preserve the status quo. For the great majority of children it will probably be found desirable to have much more outdoor education in the country. And for older boys and girls whose

fears I believe to be groundless. See above, (Chapter IV, on ``Work and Pay.'' Also,

ers will be no longer operative. Those who nevertheless still do commit crimes will not be blamed or regarded as wicked; they will be regarded as unfortunate, and kept in some kind of mental hospital until it is thought that they are no longer a danger. By education and freedom and the abolition of private capital the n

le, submit to it when it is passed, because resistance is generally useless in a settled and orderly community. But the possibility of governmental force remains, and indeed is the very reason for the submission which makes force unnecessary. If, as Anarchists desire, there were no use of force by government, the majority could still band themselves together and use force against the minority. The o

sts within a country: it is the State. But in international affairs it remains to be created. The difficulties are stupendous, but they must be overcome if the world is to be saved from periodical wars, each more destructive than any of its predecessors. Whether, after this war, a League of Nations will be formed, and will be capable of performing this task, it is as yet impossible to foretell. However that may be, some method of preve

ernal affairs should be given, not only to areas, but to all groups, such as industries or Churches, which have important common interests not shared by the rest of the community. (2) The great powers vested in the executive of a modern State are chiefly due to the frequent need of rapid decisions, especially as regards foreign affairs. If the danger of war were practically eliminated, more cumbrous but less autocratic methods would be possible, and the Legislature might recover many of the powers which the executive has usurped. By these two methods, the intensity of the interference with liberty involved in government can be gradually diminished. Some interference, and even some danger of unwarranted and despotic interference, is of the essence of government, and must

ve outlined bear on the evils of character? I believe

s of others than any man ought to have; his friends have authority in the State; his economic power is the pattern for political power. In a world where all men and women enjoy economic freedom, there will not be the same habit of command, nor, consequently, the same love of despotism; a gentler type of c

labor. In such a world, most of the nightmares that lurk in the background of men's minds will no longer exist; on the other hand, ambition and the desire to excel will have to take nobler forms than those that are encouraged by a commercial society. All those activities that really confer benefits upon mankind will be open, not only to the fortunate few, but to all who have sufficient ambition and native aptitude. Science, labor-saving inventions, technical progress of all kinds, may be confidently expected to flourish far more than at present, since they will be the road to honor, and honor will have to replace money among those of the young who desire to achi

vils of prostitution are generally recognized, but, great as they are, the effect of economic conditions on marriage seems to me even worse. There is not infrequently, in marriage, a suggestion of purchase, of acquiring a woman on condition of keeping her in a certain standard of material comfort. Often and often, a marriage hardly differs from prostitution except by being harder to escape from. The whole basis of these evils is economic. Economic causes make marriage a matter of bargain and contract, in which affection is quite secondary, and its absence constitutes no recognized reason for liberation. Marriage should be a free, spontaneous meeting of mutual instinct, filled with happiness not unmixed with a feeling akin to awe: it should involve that degree of respect of each for the other that makes even th

find in private life an outlet and stimulus to the love of domineering, but all that is creative in their love will have the freer scope. Reverence for whatever makes the soul in those who are loved will be less rare than it is now: nowadays, many men love their wives in the way in which they love mutton, as something to devour and destroy. But

s. The advice to ``become as little children'' would be good for many people in many respects, but it goes with another precept, ``take no thought for the morrow,'' which is hard to obey in a competitive world. There is often in men of science, even when they are quite old, something of the simplicity of a child: their abso

s illness than there is at present? Will the produce of a given amount of labor be greater? Or will po

n. Will men in such a world become lazy and apathetic? Will they cease to think? Will those who do think find themselves confronted with an even more impenetrable wall of unreflecting c

than there is at present. Population will no longer be congested in slums; children will have far more of fresh air and

es will not be made, because, until they have been made, they will seem too doubtful to warrant the expenditure of public money upon them. Authority will be in the hands of the old, especially of men who have achieved scientific eminence; such men

e'' to those who desired to pursue some study so new as to be wholly unrecognized, there is every reason to think that science would flourish as it h

n of this question in

a term of years the advantages, or part of the advantages, of any new invention or methods which it introduced, it is pretty certain that every encouragement would be given to technical progress. The life of a discoverer or inventor is in itself agreeable: those who adopt it, as things are now, are seldom much actuated by economic motives, but rather by the interest of the work together with th

e effects of the war are taken into account, the population of Western Europe is not likely to increase very much beyond its present level, and that of America is likely only to increase through immigration. Negroes may continue to increase in the tropics, but are not likely to be a serious menace to the white inhabitants of temperate regions. There remains, of course, the Yellow Peril; but by the time that begins to be serio

icient. There are various forms of Socialism: the form in which the State is the employer, and all who work receive wages from it, involves dangers of tyranny and interference with progress which would make it, if possible, even worse than the present regime. On the other hand, Anarchism, which avoids the dangers of State Socialism, has dangers and difficulties of its own, which make it probable that, withi

relations, and the joy of life -that Anarchism is strongest, and it is chiefly for the sake of these things that we included such more or less Anarchist proposals as the ``vagabond's wage.'' It is by its effects outside econo

in what we possess or to seize what is possessed by others. It must be a world in which affection has free play, in which love is purged of the instinct for domination, in which cruelty and envy have b

rned up in the fire of its own hot passions; and from its ashes will spring a n

N

ff., 198 ff. and violence, 33, 52-4, 72, 121 ff. and distribution, 93 ff. and wages, 96 ff. anti-German, 46 attitude to syndicalism, 79 congress in Amsterdam, 79 Ants, 152 Army, private, 120, 123 Art, 109, 111

German, 45 and production, 50 Bebel, 66 Benbow, William, 71 n. Bergson, 68 Bernstein, 27-29, 56 Bevington, 53 Bismarck, 30 Books under Socialism, 178 Bornstedt, 39

ero,

, 6, 10

lism,

ar, 1

ornia

of pl

pion

n, Brou

ng-gu

, 137

ist

ng T

ches

Servic

xvi, 9 ff.,

11

ence

den

). H., 89n

81n.,

nism,

1, 38ff.,

., 1

Manifest

4,

itiven

tion of C

8,

ation Ge

, 63-65

f Bread, T

tine, 1

veness

e, 1

ion, int

maraich

win

eon

2, 30, 129

Jahrbu

ution

mamen

aeli

bution

s, Fe

ling

anique, 48 Engels, 3, 6, 17, 38 Envy, 160-169 Evils- physical, 188

ian

, 18

alis

Factor

ps, 80,

e and

and,

ier,

ssian War,

lin,

m, see

, Lloy

ommunist

Worki

ciat

any,

Lione

the St

win

per

ls, T

t, 111 ff

ve, 117, 129

, Jule

gress, 83

lism, xi, 8

2,

State, 8

8

e, James

woo

ge

insti

bne

, mater

retati

, J. A

skin

, T.

cris

ess,

nt Labor

ia,

vidu

Relations

ssion

al Worke

.W.W.),

al alliance

crac

onal frat

onal Work

ion, 6,

ionalism

an,

res

hau

f Lif

6, 46, 80-61, 87 ff., 96n., 100n., 102

uis, 69n., 60n. Liberal Party, 28, 30 Liberty, 111 ff., 192, 201 and syndicalism, 85 and a

Traff

ederatio

tics

hing

trate

divine right

86 ff.,

ester

iage

-31, 36, 6

6

raph

nes, 7

kunin,

rnationa

sociatio

9

, La dec

,

zin

um by fo

rand,

ton

Western

76

ey,

Doctr

ng St

, Will

leon

eon I

fred, 98n.

l Guild

Guilds

sm, 17, 2

ti

ns of,

of, 1

es, free?

nische Z

as, Ts

Singer

Traffi

ge,

Robe

o, Sil

tier,

eati

sia

to,

ts,

d, 37

ation

bilis

rty,

e of, 111,

6

ss,

, methods

ariat,

nal Repre

6

hon,

acit

ment,

chol

one, Pi

, Elis

onism,

olu

nch

18, 67,

17, 70, 113

6

48, 3

ge

tage

-Simo

George

jevo

ships,

6, 109, 13

9,

of

nteres

free, 9

ley,

le T

ery,

ism, p

ine

lis

ch,

man

tiona

107, 115,

202

ribution

nd scienc

0

ee Guild

t Labor

evolutionar

,

s, Inter-

l, 2

oza,

xi, 1, 16,

-4, 107 ff

6, 67, 70,

alism,

arx,

part

ibert

ical acti

9

chism, x

ance,

taly

and revo

ss-war,

al strike

3

State,

d Social

3

ist Rail

icat

ffs,

Training,

ft,

n, Will

sto

ionism,

ial, 31

ft,

s, 75

s, vii

's wage,

8,

es Saint

crimes of,

9

Reflecti

ian

timme

teers

, 78, 9$

law o

nd scienc

, Rich

Rousseau

, Mary

a

e of, 13

italism

Press

me

s fo

indepen

9

o

es, 93

f, 102,

e made p

193

races,