icon 0
icon TOP UP
rightIcon
icon Reading History
rightIcon
icon Sign out
rightIcon
icon Get the APP
rightIcon

The Boy I Wasn't Supposed to Love

Chapter 5 Bargaining With The Unexpected

Word Count: 1818    |    Released on: 03/02/2026

her room then I closed my eyes, picturing myself as Catherine. I imagined the feeling of having an exciting birthday party surrounded by friends, being the

nice looking as Matthew. As I admired the dress, I realized I'd rather spend my birthday with Matthew than invite the whole class. I didn't like any of them anyways, they w

empowering to stand up to Catherin

esent

reality. "You should have done what earlier? I'm talking you, but you

e smile on your

realized that the scene I had thought

with you" Catherine

were saying?" trying to hide my d

Catherine asked angrily. "Didn't

pretended to have heard her but didn't. She hadn't taken it wel

ng again right?" Catherine said, "

ded a

ark would be at th

ould have been so impolite to wake people up for something as a birthday party. I planned to check back

d said he'd make su

and there daydreaming, get back to wor

ty, but I still saw the anxiety etched on her face. She's clearly still hopin

f Mark doesn't come, Catherine would kill

d as I picked up the thing

t getting caught by Veronica. I was currently trapped between a r

rfectly. She had already made it clear to everyone that there'll b

ement for what you'd feel i

especially me. I was the most clumsy but given the entire major task. It felt like Catherine

elt like my life depended on it. I just kn

d enough. Mark's house wasn't far, I just had to be quick. I

ds, the door opened, and I found myself face-to-face with the ring leader. I

I help you

calmly, avoiding his gaze in the

or Mark," I

im for?" He asked,

ith the question?" But respond

spit it out. I'm all ears. I really don't

ning out of time here, I should be t

rry, but I'd like to t

ell, you are looking at

shock. "You're Mark?

living in this house ex

re always teasing every girl they see pass by them. It seemed fitting, giving his personality, that he wo

"Well, Catherine....", but he shut the door in my face as soo

essage yet. Don't you know it's rude to slam the

e door, " Well, I know what you want to

't attend Catherine's party, things would go terribly wrong for me. I walked back to the door and knocked agai

Don't you have any man

ft we with no other

birthday parties, but can you please just

gly unimpressed. "And why shou

take pity on me. "I know you don't h

eps inviting me every year," Mark sa

dy have my parents nagging me about it, a

rents, should I now liste

you calling a m

rine is your villain. You should go, I do

o to the party and confront her, tell her to stop sending invitation

Put an end? Are you silly

sted in finishing. Don't you know her expectations would on

nion, so please take your dumb advice

mstances, I just had to plead with him. "It's not my place to

y was piqued. "

imagine anything going well today if you don't c

ollowed, "So you'

ent as the ans

in. "Look, Mark, I don't have the time to keep up

be there?"

to join the party

couldn't care

iate. "Then I won't go,"

I said. "You have to come: I

hoice, Minion. You can't make me,"

me. I had no idea what to do next, an

and called out to Mark. "If I join th

Mark looked at me suspiciousl

"Fine, but you can't go back on

as casual. "Sure,

f fun at the party than face consequences of Mark not showing up. The thought of being humiliated

t help but feel angry at

liated, but that was what I should expect from him

Claim Your Bonus at the APP

Open
The Boy I Wasn’t Supposed to Love
The Boy I Wasn't Supposed to Love
“Orphaned young and taken in by Veronica, Lucy's learned that trust is dangerous and kindness even rarer. Starting at Catherine's elite school should be a fresh start, but new friendships come with jealousy, betrayal, and secrets that won't stay buried. Matthew, her first love, pulls her in through shared history and familiarity, only to betray her trust, while Mark who she least trusted became fiercely protective which lead to their closeness-until the secrets he keeps force Lucy to question his feelings and her faith in him. As family truths come to light, Lucy must decide who deserves her trust and whether love can survive when it's built on half-truths.”
1 Chapter 1 Just Friends 2 Chapter 2 The Cost of Misunderstanding3 Chapter 3 Before It Began4 Chapter 4 Crush or Crushed5 Chapter 5 Bargaining With The Unexpected6 Chapter 6 Tough Exterior, Gently Gesture7 Chapter 7 Divided We Stand8 Chapter 8 A Conversation Earned9 Chapter 9 A Night to Remember10 Chapter 10 A Glimpse of Vulnerability11 Chapter 11 Forbidden Conversation12 Chapter 12 Bruised and Broken13 Chapter 13 Beneath the Surface14 Chapter 14 A Shared Sorrow15 Chapter 15 A Fragile Heart16 Chapter 16 When Loyalties Clash17 Chapter 17 More Than Eyes Meet18 Chapter 18 The Zoner19 Chapter 19 The Rumor20 Chapter 20 The Period Incident21 Chapter 21 A Night Out22 Chapter 22 A Night of Concern23 Chapter 23 The Harrison Scandal24 Chapter 24 Mark's Devotion25 Chapter 25 Unbroken Loyalty26 Chapter 26 The Escape27 Chapter 27 The Unlikely Ally28 Chapter 28 Shadows Before Dawn29 Chapter 29 A Plan Takes Shape30 Chapter 30 Pursuing Leads31 Chapter 31 Into The Unknown32 Chapter 32 Shadows of Danger33 Chapter 33 Midnight Reckoning34 Chapter 34 Unwavering Valor35 Chapter 35 The Edge of Escape36 Chapter 36 One Last Breath, One Last Chance37 Chapter 37 Quiet After the Storm38 Chapter 38 Normal Days, Unsettled Hearts39 Chapter 39 Almost Peaceful40 Chapter 40 Danger Wears A Smile41 Chapter 41 Where the Rain Found Us