Carter Monteiro is a very sweet, caring and loving guy, but the mere mention of Athena's name, made his personality flips and swirls. She just irritates him and it doesn't help that Athena is not making any effort for him to like her. She provokes him as much as possible.
Athena hates Carter. For her, he's the reincarnated Lucifer. Everything she does, he contradicts. He said that she's reckless, irresponsible, rebellious and could not make a right decision. Worse of all, he thought that she's the dumbest person on earth! If only he knows.
Are their personalities just really don't match? Or there's something going on that they themselves only know. Do they really hate each other or they're just pretending?
"Quit playing games with my heart, Carter."
"Then, don't shut me out, Athena."