The Chef's Lie, Her Scars

Anastasia Paige

Modern | Completed

5.0

Comment(s)

View

Chapters

My husband Collin and I were Chicago' s culinary power couple, but our perfect life was a lie. To win the coveted Golden Spoon award, he brought in a protégée, Casey-a woman who looked just like me, twenty years younger. Then I overheard his sickening plan. He would use my talent to win the award, securing our empire. After that, he' d set Casey up as his adoring mistress in Europe. "I get to have both," he bragged. "The respectable chef wife, the passionate, adoring mistress. It's perfect." He publicly humiliated me, abandoned me after a kitchen fire left my arm scarred, and painted me as a jealous, unstable woman when I caught them together. He thought I was too devoted to our restaurant, too blinded by love to ever see his betrayal. He was wrong. The final straw wasn't his affair, but his cruelty. After he left me bleeding on the street to rush Casey to the hospital for a minor scratch, I finally saw the truth. I would not just leave him. I would vanish, erasing myself from his life so completely that he'd be left with nothing but the ashes of the empire I built.

Betrayal Rebirth Second chance Personal growth Ex-wife

Chapter 21

01-06 22:34

Chapter 1

Then I overheard his sickening plan. He would use my talent to win the award, securing our empire. After that, he' d set Casey up as his adoring mistress in Europe.

"I get to have both," he bragged. "The respectable chef wife, the passionate, adoring mistress. It's perfect."

He publicly humiliated me, abandoned me after a kitchen fire left my arm scarred, and painted me as a jealous, unstable woman when I caught them together. He thought I was too devoted to our restaurant, too blinded by love to ever see his betrayal.

He was wrong.

The final straw wasn't his affair, but his cruelty. After he left me bleeding on the street to rush Casey to the hospital for a minor scratch, I finally saw the truth. I would not just leave him. I would vanish, erasing myself from his life so completely that he'd be left with nothing but the ashes of the empire I built.

Chapter 1

Emma Carpenter POV:

The chill that ran through me when Collin brought up Casey Nash wasn't from the Chicago wind; it was the kind that settled deep in your bones, a premonition I tried to ignore.

Collin and I, Emma Carpenter, we were Chicago' s culinary darlings, the perfect power couple. Everyone saw the glossy magazine covers, the packed restaurant, the awards lining our shelves. They saw the dazzling smile Collin reserved for public appearances, the way he' d pull me close for a photo, his hand a warm, possessive weight on my lower back. They saw a woman who had it all.

I saw the hollow echo in our penthouse at night.

I saw the way his eyes would glaze over when I spoke about a new recipe, a new flavor profile I was excited about. "Sounds great, Em," he'd say, already scrolling through his phone. Our once passionate conversations about food, about our dreams, had long since withered into pragmatic business discussions.

The deep missing in our relationship was a chasm I built walls around with work, with the clatter of pans and the organized chaos of a busy kitchen. It was easier to ignore the silence in our bed if I was exhausted enough to simply fall into it.

"Kids are messy, Emma," he' d said once, years ago, when the subject of starting a family came up. He' d barely looked up from his financial reports. "They complicate things. Our empire – it needs our full attention. You're too talented to be stuck changing diapers."

He' d always framed it as a compliment, a sacrifice for our shared success. And I, desperate to believe we shared anything truly important, had bought it. I loved him. Or, I loved the man I thought he was, the man who had whispered sweet promises into my ear, who had once looked at me like I was the most exquisite dish he'd ever tasted.

He' d been so convincing. "You are my world, Emma. Everything I do, I do for us, for our future." His words, a silken trap, had bound me tighter than any vow.

I poured my entire being into that restaurant. It wasn't just a business; it was my child, my creative outlet, my legacy. It was the place where I felt alive, where I felt seen, even if only by the ingredients themselves. It was my consolation prize for the family we never had, for the emotional intimacy that had evaporated into thin air.

Then Eldridge Emerson, the shark of the food industry, dropped his bombshell. "Golden Spoon Award, Collin. Win it, or I pull my funding." His voice had been flat, devoid of emotion, a death sentence for everything we'd built.

Panic had gripped me. The Golden Spoon wasn't just an award; it was a legend, a career-defining honor. Collin, ever the strategist, had responded with a calm that unnerved me. "Don't worry, Em. I've got a plan."

A plan. The word felt like a tiny, sharp stone in my shoe. I wanted to trust him, to believe in his unwavering confidence. Hope, a fragile bird, fluttered in my chest. If we won, maybe the pressure would lift. Maybe he would see me again, not just as his business partner, but as his wife. "What is it?" I asked, my voice barely a whisper.

He' d smiled, a smooth, practiced curve of his lips that didn' t quite reach his eyes. "We need fresh blood, new energy. A protégé. Someone to inject some competitive fire into the kitchen, push us to the next level."

He'd found her within a week. Casey Nash. Her resume was impressive, raw talent honed at some of the best culinary schools. But it was her face that made my breath catch. She was me, twenty years younger, with the same strong jawline, the same intense eyes, the same cascade of dark, curly hair. A striking image, a mirror image, yet somehow... brighter. Unburdened.

"She's... quite something," I'd mumbled, trying to sound professional when Collin first showed me her headshot.

"Isn't she?" Collin's voice had a strange lilt, an almost proprietorial tone that sent another shiver down my spine. "A diamond in the rough. Just needs a little polishing."

I pushed the unease aside. This was for the restaurant. For us. Collin knew best, right? He always had. "Okay," I said, forcing a smile. "Let's bring her in."

He' d wrapped an arm around my waist, pulling me close. His scent, usually a comfort, felt cloying that day. "See? I told you everything would be fine. We' ll win this, Em. Together." He kissed my temple, a gesture that felt more like a brand than affection.

I believed him. I wanted to believe him. I desperately clung to the idea that his love for me, for our life, was real, a foundation that could withstand any pressure. It was easier than facing the chill that was slowly, steadily creeping into our perfect, glittering facade.

The deception began subtly, a slow, insidious poison. Collin's "mentoring" sessions with Casey stretched longer and longer. He' d arrive home late, his clothes smelling faintly of her perfume – a different, sweeter scent than mine – and a tired but exhilarated look on his face. "Long day in the kitchen," he'd say, kissing my cheek with a practiced ease. "Casey's a quick learner. Got real potential."

"Of course," I'd respond, trying to sound supportive, trying to ignore the knot tightening in my stomach. He' d started getting texts at odd hours, always from "work" or "Eldridge." I' d catch glimpses of his screen-a name, "Casey," flashing before he quickly tucked it away.

I cooked him his favorite dishes. I left his clothes laid out. I tried to initiate conversations, to bridge the growing silence between us. I was trying to mend a crack I didn't yet realize was a gaping wound.

My birthday came and went. A text message from Collin, "Happy Birthday, Em! Stuck in a meeting. Dinner soon?" Dinner never happened.

Our anniversary. Another text. "Thinking of you, babe. Crazy day." I spent the evening alone in our penthouse, a bottle of expensive wine untouched on the counter, the silence louder than ever. I made excuses for him, for us. He was under pressure. The Golden Spoon was everything. He was just stressed. He still loved me; he had to.

Then the accident. A gas leak in the prep kitchen, a flash fire. I was too close, trying to douse the flames. My arm, my dominant arm, took the brunt of it. Pain, searing and immediate, ripped through me. I called Collin, my voice shaking, adrenaline making my heart pound like a drum.

"Emergency, Collin. I'm hurt. The restaurant..."

His voice, distant and annoyed, crackled through the phone. "Em? Now? I'm with Eldridge. Can't it wait? Just call the manager, darling."

He hung up.

I stood there, singed and bleeding, the phone still warm in my hand, the dial tone a mocking buzz in my ear. The manager, bless his heart, helped me to the hospital. The doctors wrapped my arm, their faces grim. Collin didn't show. Not then, not that night. Not even the next day.

It wasn't until I was back at the penthouse, my arm in a heavy cast, that he finally breezed in, a bouquet of generic flowers in hand. "Oh, Em! My poor darling, I'm so sorry! Eldridge had me tied up. How are you?" He leaned in to kiss my forehead, but I flinched, the pain too raw, too deep to pretend.

I started to notice things. Small details. A faint, sweet scent on Collin's collar. A stray, long dark hair on his jacket – not mine, mine was lighter, streaked with silver I'd earned in that very kitchen. I found a tiny, diamante earring, clearly not mine, nestled between the couch cushions. The seed of doubt, once a tiny speck, began to take root, growing into a thorny, poisonous vine.

The final straw came, not with a bang, but with a whisper. It was the annual Culinary Gala, the kind of event where champagne flowed and reputations were made or broken. Collin had insisted I come, despite my still-healing arm. "You're the face of the restaurant, Emma. We need you."

I'd slipped away from the main hall, needing a moment of quiet, a breath of air. I found myself near a half-open door, the muffled voices of Collin and someone else drifting out. I recognized his laugh, low and warm, the one he rarely used with me anymore. My heart began to pound, a frantic drumbeat in my ears.

"She's good, Collin," a woman's voice said, sounding vaguely familiar. "Casey's really talented. But..."

"But she's not Emma," Collin finished, his tone dismissive. "No, she's not. Emma's the genius, the one who'll secure the Golden Spoon for us. The one who'll keep Eldridge happy and the money flowing."

A cold dread seeped into my veins. I pressed myself closer to the door, my breath catching in my throat.

"So, what's the plan then?" the woman asked. It was Chloe, Collin' s old college friend, a gossip disguised as an confidante.

Collin chuckled, a self-satisfied sound that made my skin crawl. "Emma wins the award, secures our empire. Then, once everything's settled, I set Casey up with her own place. Maybe in Europe. Somewhere chic. She's young, ambitious, adores me. I get to have both. The respectable chef wife, the passionate, adoring mistress. It's perfect."

My world shattered. The words hit me like a physical blow, stealing the air from my lungs. Both. He wanted both. My love, my talent, my life – it was all just a chess piece in his game, a means to an end. Casey, a younger version of me, was the prize, the new toy he' d play with once I' d served my purpose.

I felt a wave of nausea, my vision blurring. The room spun. The glittering lights of the gala, the distant murmur of happy chatter, it all felt grotesque, a cruel mockery.

"You really think you can have your cake and eat it too, Collin?" Chloe' s voice, a hint of skepticism in it.

"Of course." His voice was laced with arrogant confidence. "I always do. Emma's too devoted, too focused on the restaurant. She'll never see it coming. And Casey... Casey will do anything I ask."

A choked sob escaped my lips, a tiny, involuntary sound. It was enough.

The voices inside the room abruptly stopped. The doorknob rattled.

Panic, cold and sharp, seized me. I stumbled backward, clutching my throbbing arm, desperate to disappear. But it was too late. The door swung open, revealing Collin, his eyes narrowed, his face a mask of surprise, then something colder. His gaze swept over my pale, tear-streaked face, the fresh bandages on my arm. Guilt flashed in his eyes, quickly replaced by irritation.

"Emma?" he asked, his voice sharp, devoid of the warmth I had just overheard him use. "What are you doing here?"

I stared at him, my heart a raw, bleeding wound in my chest. My lips trembled, but no words came out. He looked at me, then past me, his eyes already calculating, dismissive.

He moved toward me, a hand reaching for my arm, a show of concern for Chloe's benefit. His touch felt like acid. "Darling, you look terrible. Are you alright? Your arm..."

"Don't," I rasped, recoiling from his touch. The word was a fragile thread, barely holding my world together. "Just... don't." His eyes hardened. He knew.

"What's wrong, Emma?" His voice was low, laced with a false concern that made my stomach churn. He didn't care. Not about me. Only about what I had just heard.

My gaze flickered to Chloe in the background, her face a mixture of shock and morbid curiosity.

Then, a thought, cold and clear, cut through my despair. He thought he could have everything. He thought he could use me, discard me, and still profit from my broken heart. A bitter, ironic laugh bubbled up, a sound so alien it startled me.

"She's... she's just a raw talent, Collin," I said, my voice surprisingly steady, a whisper of steel underneath. My eyes locked onto his, stripping away the mask he wore. "A phase. A fleeting fancy." I watched his face, searching for a flicker of recognition, a hint of shame. There was none. Only annoyance.

He scoffed, a dismissive sound. "Emma, what are you talking about? You're being dramatic. You heard nothing." He tried to usher me away, his grip firm on my uninjured arm.

But something had shifted inside me. The desperation, the blind devotion, it had all burned away in the fire of his betrayal. There was only a chilling clarity left.

"You really think so?" I asked, my voice flat, empty. "You think she'll be enough? A younger version of me, a pale imitation." I pulled my arm away from his grasp. "You're a fool, Collin. A pathetic, deluded fool."

His eyes widened, finally registering the venom in my words, the complete absence of the pleading, heartbroken wife he expected. He opened his mouth, but I didn't wait for his lies.

I turned and walked away, past Chloe's shocked face, past the murmuring crowd, a dead woman walking. The Gala, the lights, the laughter – it all faded into a dull roar behind me. I had just witnessed the complete destruction of my life, but in its ashes, a new, terrifying resolve had begun to smolder. He wanted his empire. He wanted his mistress. He could have them. But he would never have me again.